Tuesday, 15 November 2016

Comparing 'A Touch of Evil' and 'The Departed'

There are many similarities between the plot line and character profiles which make us consider whether Scorsese based his ideas on Welles original of 'A touch of Evil'.


Plot




       • Both ‘A touch of Evil’ and ‘The Departed’ involve crime scene and police lead plots that display the corrupt policing and law system in place. Both plots rely a large amount on audience misconception, both constantly mislead to trigger certain impressions about each character
In     Also in narratives there is a hunt for a ‘rat’, someone working for both sides of the police force. This is important as it demonstrates how corrupt the system appears to be, when considering how many cops are working for both sides.



Characters


     •Hank Quinlan’s character has an obvious link to the personality of Frank Costello. This is especially shown in the way the deaths of both these characters mirror each other, these are both killed by their accomplices. They both share similar lines also: “I never killed/framed someone who didn’t already have it coming/wasn’t guilty.” Aggression is also a key trait between these characters.



Colin Sullivan’s character is similar to the one of Pete Menzies. Menzies character is caught trying to plant evidence on a convict, similarly Sullivan’s character plays the ‘rat’ of the narrative and cannot be trusted. Eventually both characters turn in colleges in need for power and “status quo”. Both of the characters die at the end of the narrative and they both kill their bosses.



Billy’s character is similar to Mike Vargas, as they both reveal the truth about the ‘rats’ within each of the narratives and give answers and direction.



Camera Angles and Lighting



Displays of Hank Quinlan are usually from a low angle. This is to present the sinister and intimidating role he plays. At this particular low angle the light always catches the rim of his hat always catches a the light, this creates the impression of a thin halo above his head. Possibly illustrating how there is a fraction of morality about Quinlan that never quite gets uncovered, due to his early death.

















No comments:

Post a Comment